What in the world is SRB2 Workshop?

[Hammerhead]

original stuff made for said fangame.

what if the mod doesn't contain any sonic related content; i.e only original stuff

 

[glaber]

Heck Sega even encourages fangames and rom hacks to the point that they have a steam workshop for the genesis classic collection.

 

[skeletondome]

original stuff made for said fangame.

and??? does it being in a sonic fangame mean you should take it and do whatever you want with it against the author's wishes??

 

[chromaticpipe]

Things get messier once you realize the fact that it is open source, What if you make a source code mod that turns the game into some other original game idea

 

[Hammerhead]

well that's what you guys do sense sega gave you the ok.

 

[glaber]

Even the Gmod and Source Film Maker communities are more respectful than the SRB2 workshop as they will remove a re-upload if the original author wishes, but not the SRB2 Workshop. Speaking from experience on this one.

 

[SP Moves Enjoyer]

so then, what's the point here exactly? if someone allows you to use their copyrighted material, then it is NOT copyright infringement.

 

[Hammerhead]

than why does sega still have rights to sonic?

so then, what's the point here exactly? if someone allows you to use their copyrighted material, then it is NOT copyright infringement.

 

[SP Moves Enjoyer]

than why does sega still have rights to sonic?

because.... they created him? I don't know how this is supposed to prove anything

 

[skeletondome]

than why does sega still have rights to sonic?

what part of "if someone allows you to use their copyrighted material, then it is NOT copyright infringement" do you not understand

 

[Hammerhead]

but you just said that they allowed us to use it.

 

[skeletondome]

but you just said that they allowed us to use it.

correct. nice observation

 

[glaber]

What matters is when money is involved and I only know one company to allow you yo use their IP and make money, but you have to sell it on their platform. Valve.

 

[Mr Beagle]

Studios have the right to set rules when it comes to fans making use of their IP's. Sega happens to be one of the friendlier and less restrictive studios at least when it comes to the Sonic roster.

This is the reason why you do not see any highly developed fangames based on Nintendo franchises. Nintendo though recently 'endorsed' fan game creation, but only if you purchase and use their limited game making toy (Game Builder Garage) for the Switch which will not allow a quality that gets close to the official titles.

 

[Hammerhead]

so then, what's the point here exactly? if someone allows you to use their copyrighted material, then it is NOT copyright infringement.

Just because Sega says it's ok to make fangames doesn't mean that you're no longer infringing on the brand.

 

[SP Moves Enjoyer]

Just because Sega says it's ok to make fangames doesn't mean that you're no longer infringing on the brand.

yes it does?!

 

[Sandwichface]

if someone allows you to use their copyrighted material, then it is NOT copyright infringement.

Except Sega has never explicitly stated anything of the sort anywhere.
Their position isn't "we have allowed this and anyone can do whatever they want", it's "we don't care and we won't do anything about it unless we have to".
Contrary to popular belief, Sega has taken down Sonic fan projects and other unlicensed projects made with their IPs before, Sonic Eclipse Online and a fan remake of Streets of Rage being major examples of this.

 

[skeletondome]

Just because Sega says it's ok to make fangames doesn't mean that you're no longer infringing on the brand.

"just because i said you can have something doesn't mean you're not stealing it from me"

 

[Hammerhead]

"just because i said you can have something doesn't mean you're not stealing it from me"

"Just because i let you use something doesn't mean you can misuse it"

 

[skeletondome]

"Just because i let you use something doesn't mean you can misuse it"

how is anyone misusing it