Sonic But BAD v2

Typically, jokes are funny. I mean-- I guess here, the joke is that you thought it was a good bad joke. That's funny in its own way, but not because it was trying to be.

On the bright side, you can't get a rating any worse than this!

It *does* accomplish what it sets out to do, at least.
Might be pretty funny if you reskinned the entire game like your inspiration did -- at least then, you'd get some value out of a full playthrough.

I'm sorry but this just looks like a shitty mod, as you know i'm aware that this is your first mod but it isn't that good. sure you said it's inspired by fnf but bad but this is just a sonic with a bunch of reusable lua. The Super music doesn't even load and gives me a bunch of errors, i find mcsonic more enjoyable then this.

If you look beyond the "amoogoos" and the crappy sprites, this feels empty, without anything unique, maybe add/revise a few features.

obligatory "intentionally bad thing funny" mod : |
you get a star for vine boom thok though that cracked me up

Sure hes kinda fun but my goodness the sprites could you at least removed the white pixels

Was expecting something else from the gameplay but besides that the rest is bad, good job. (Tho I still echo what the others say about making an non-joke mod)

I’m going to be completely blunt, this mod stinks. I know you think that means you did what you set out to do, but you failed to do that by a long shot. I’m going to criticize what this mod does right and what it does wrong. I feel like I’m in a position to make this review simply because I’m making a mod of a similar nature.

1. The Moveset - He’s playable, but it’s very generic. There’s not much going for it. I could easily get a better experience by playing MCSonic.

2. The Sprites - You kinda hit the mark, but it looks like a very basic and uninspired version of TerminalMontage’s Sonic, which is also a very basic design. Kudos on actually making all 200+ sprites (I’m hoping you did, I haven’t opened it up in Slade yet), but that’s the only positive that I’ll give you. No real effort seems to show through the character’s design.

3. The Memes - Holy cannoli, this was a very rough way of intertwining memes into it. First off, you should know that memes expire. Second off, you should already know that the memes included have already expired. The “I like ya cut, G” Scream and Amogus have been dead for a long time, so this just comes off as very cringey and out of the loop.

4. The Inspiration - So, you mentioned how this is based off of the “Friday Night Funkin’ But Bad” Mod, but it doesn’t feel that way at all. First off, FNFBB isn’t overloaded with memes. Second off, the “But Bad” refers to the poor drawings and poor audio. There’s people that took actual effort to make super basic designs of the characters and the stages to give it an unfinished look and, on top of that, actually demastered the audio to sound really unfinished. This mod does neither of those particularly well.

For a first mod, this shows you have an understanding of how to use Slade. That’s it. I do hope you take these criticisms to heart and take it with you when you decide to take modding more seriously.

Sorry, bud. There's a big difference between "tolerable cringe" and... this.

Ah... were to begin with this... Your sprites are terrible, this is filled to the brim with bad memes, and this looks EXACTLY like a friend of mines. So, calling it "bad" just upsets me in every way. I get this is a joke but you didn't make it funny, If you're a beginner at modding you should have just made a normal mod. The DJ version crashed on me so luckily I won't complain about that, though that would have made it worse because I already wish I can give this zero stars.