Official Level Design Contest Voting: March/April 2009

[Srb2kirbyo]

Mill Citadel Zone by Ezer.Arch: 9N89888878688788XX8796 = 8

Congratulations to Ezer.Arch and winning the contest!

Hurray!!
Congratulations Ezer.Arch!! *shakes hand*

I have cakes for all contenders!!

 

[wise.rain]

Whoops, I forgot to add Darkvile Castle's score to my post. Updated, but I guess it's a little late for it. It doesn't change his score much anyway.

 

[Ezer'Arch]

Ok, I guess I'll do the results.
(...)
N represents a dropped vote, while X represents a perfect score.

Are you sure results values are all correct? There's a slight difference between your values and my values calculated by MS Excel (0.1~0.2).

Congratulations Ezer.Arch!! *shakes hand*

Hey, my hand! Not so strong. o.O'

According to my calculations, Vibrant Vendetta is in first place at the time of this post, with Mill Citadel not far behind. Can you beat me, Ezer'Arch? >=D

Now that results are out, can I answer it? :)

 

[Mikel]

Ok, I guess I'll do the results.
(...)
N represents a dropped vote, while X represents a perfect score.

Are you sure results values are all correct? There's a slight difference between your values and my values calculated by MS Excel (0.1~0.2)

I used MS Calculator to calculate the results, so yeah, there might be some errors.

 

[Monsteriestyn]

As long as both answers reveal that Ezer.Arch, HyperKnux, and Blade are the winners, then it's not that big a deal. Specially with the wiki being closed down for the moment.

 

[clairebun]

Do note that I rely on the scores for the BOOLDC, though. The more accurate the calculations are, the better for me.

 

[Thompson]

Meh. I only wanted to show some of my originality level making skills, since some people thought all I could do is port stuff.

 

[Ezer'Arch]

Ah! you Mr. Thompson. I've just remembered a thing.

I'm gonna send you a PM there in WadBase, replying a PM sent by you.

*evil grin* >:D

 

[Blade]

Congrats to everyone that won!

Also, my map is also 4th overall in the race division.

 

[Eblo]

Ezer'Arch has been taking the cake for far too long D:

 

[Jellybones]

Ezer'Arch has been taking the cake for far too long D:

Cause he deserves caek.

 

[Scarbo the Black Sheep]

Mikel has calculated a different score on every single Single Player level in the contest than I did. I think all the ones of his that don't match mine are lower than what I calculated. The contest winners are still the same in each of our calculations, though.

Do you want me to upload my Excel spreadsheet?

Edit: I know you said it's not much of a deal right now because the Wiki is down and the winners are the same either way, Chaos Zero 64. This DOES affect the "Current Records" division of the Wiki page (for Mill Citadel), and really, I want us to make sure we have the right scores.

 

[clairebun]

Again, I'd prefer the scores to be as accurate as possible, if only to ensure the accuracy of what goes in the BOOLDC next.

 

[Hyperknux]

Yay my day is getting better, first it's my 18th birthday today, and I finally set one of my achievements on here ^_^ and congrats to everyone else who won and well done for others who entered.

 

[Cue]

Mikel has calculated a different score on every single Single Player level in the contest than I did. I think all the ones of his that don't match mine are lower than what I calculated. The contest winners are still the same in each of our calculations, though.

Do you want me to upload my Excel spreadsheet?

Edit: I know you said it's not much of a deal right now because the Wiki is down and the winners are the same either way, Chaos Zero 64. This DOES affect the "Current Records" division of the Wiki page (for Mill Citadel), and really, I want us to make sure we have the right scores.

What's to say that your spreadsheet isn't wrong? As the saying goes a program is only as good as its programmer. Not saying it's wrong, but there's nothing to say it's not.

 

[Mystic]

In this case, I'd say SonicMaster is correct:

Beach Factory Zone, Act 1 by Chisuun            5624754566473455476354544 = 4.8
Water Leaf Zone by Mr. Thompson                 77777957787766786X7487    = 7
Dusty Desert Zone by Chrome                     774686465687558586886455  = 6.13
Frost Mountain Zone, Act 2 by HyperKnux         964795547576466N447656533 = 5.65
Vibrant Vendetta Zone by SonicMaster            NX889X97896X79469X4758888 = 7.96
Floating Gardens Zone by Kyasarin               4646455678657675658970534 = 5.52
Aqua Caves Zone, Act 1 by Blade T. Hedgehog     77558475858X78N687X778755 = 6.96
GS Poloy Forest by Glaber                       5N7643454545643655317331  = 4.45
Darkvile Castle Zone by Simsmagic               675565N9758666459683523   = 5.90
Mill Citadel Zone by Ezer.Arch                  98N89888878688788XX8796   = 8.10
Eggmansion Zone, Act 1 by Knockout the Echidna  65542844674878565N96456   = 5.81
MAPA1 - Heaven Meadows Zone by HyperKnux        66N54   = 5.67
MAPA2 - Great Gorge of Water Zone by SonicMaster25342   = 3.2
MAPA3 - Scale the Earth Zone by Chaobrother     0300101 = 0.71
MAPA4 - Volcano Park City by Darkness Claw      1N64443 = 4.2
MAPA5 - Scorching Factory Zone by Jellybones69  1655532 = 3.86
MAPA6 - Endless Woods Zone by Blade T. Hedgehog 97N6695 = 7.4

One vote ignored on single player due to not voting on any other map.

I don't know what Mikel screwed up, but he's definitely wrong. The winners are the same, regardless.

 

[Monsteriestyn]

Oh, that's good then. I won't have to try and figure out how to change name colors again.

 

[glaber]

I thought I had an N in there somewhere.

 

[Ezer'Arch]

Ezer'Arch has been taking the cake for far too long D:

NOM, NOM, NOM... delicious.

*scores*

Really now new results are very close to mine.

(respectively)
7.05
6.13
5.77
7.96
5.52
7.00
4.32
6.05
8.10
5.81

... but I doubt my calculations are perfect, I'd have to check out all votes.

I don't know what Mikel screwed up, but he's definitely wrong. The winners are the same, regardless.

Probably adopted method: when you drop the lowest score you need to subtract 1 voter from divisor, i.e.:

Sum of all scores / Voters = Result, should be:

(Sum of all scores - lowest score) / (Voters - 1) = Result.

If you don't subtract 1 from divisor, results will be lower than they should be. Also I saw he had dropped twice lowest scores for a map :

Darkvile Castle Zone by Simsmagic: 65565N975866645968352N = 5.5

Anyway, he was useful to inform us "preliminarily" the contest results.

Thanks Mikel.

 

[Scarbo the Black Sheep]

Meh. I only wanted to show some of my originality level making skills, since some people thought all I could do is port stuff.

Yeah, and the 7.00 score you got clearly shows that you can make much better levels than what are in Sonic 06. Congratulations on your first contest map getting a high rating.