Well, I'm curious. So what if people make super overpowered characters. I'm sure true official DM servers won't allow such character wads anyways.
Surely you played netgames with 1.X. Surely you remember how hard it was to find a netgame with characters that were remotely fair and balanced. Anyone casually trying out SRB2's netplay would end up joining a server with 500 recolor WADs, all of which were terribly overpowered.
We don't have many official servers. We have lots of casual players setting up casual games. I want to make sure that newbies joining said casual games will at least be able to play something that resembles SRB2, instead of SMS every ability in the game with maxed values glowing really bright so he doesn't need shading robo blast 2.
You can have your ugly recolor characters, but let's keep them in sane values so people who aren't retarded can play as Sonic against you and actually have a chance, please.
I mean the only reason to take out that option is to harm anyone who wishes to make a mod which, as you stated Mystic, Could in fact be based around enemies that don't get dominated by ranged 'shooting' attacks.
You say that, but nobody did that back in 1.X when it was entirely possible to do so with pure SOCs. Honestly, our enemy soccing capabilities are too limited to make a real FPS design out of it anyways. In order to do such a thing properly, you'd need a custom EXE to make challenging enemies and enable the match weapon system in single player with some kind of damage values or something. The amount of changes you'd need to make to SRB2 to turn it into a real FPS essentially makes it impossible to do it properly with just SOCs. Hence, everyone just made overpowered recolors instead.
I mean... why take it out? Why not just let it sit there, maybe make it a levelheader option or something. While yes you can always just make a custom Exe, I always like that 'look what I did with soccing alone' approach. Anyways there are my two cents, and yes someone can always just make a custom exe I suppose.
The main advantage of gimping the official EXE for this kind of thing is that the vast majority of players, and pretty much every newbie, uses the official EXE. This means a player attempting to join a game on the master server with the official EXE will always find a game with characters that abide by these standards, and someone joining a Coop game will find people playing a Sonic platformer, not some weird alternate universe where everyone can shoot projectiles at enemies that are so outgunned you might as well be shooting fish in a barrel.