The way I see it, there's a line that's getting confused on this forum: Newbies and noobs. The newbies are the ones new to the game and want to learn to make characters and stuff. When they post the stuff they want to make, they get shot down because their work isn't up to the rather large standard that's been set for them. This, in a simple way, sucks. Now, noobs are the ones that are generally retarded, like the recently banned 'theonewhoisthebest' or some crap like that. These are the people who need to be shot, murdered and disposed of in the most painful way possible. These people are the ones that you need to be rid of.
Basically, lay off the crits, this is why they're all 'noobs.'
Now, on a more related subject: I think users need to be actually worthy of getting on the Master Server, before they can get on it. IE, they need to be on the forums and they need to be decent members before getting on. This means slacking a bit on the rules.