And I'll bet that even if they gave us every little factor that played into this decision it wouldn't please the people that feel strongly about this because this really doesn't have the same priority for the team as it does for the people in this topic...
It would at least give us more to work with to take into consideration when delivering criticism and coming up with suggestions. Without all the necessary information, we will be stuck in the same situation we are in now. At least if the information wasn't being held back there's a chance the decision making process would make more sense to us and we could support their decision not to give everyone Super's more.
Assumptions like "Well it probably wouldn't satisfy you anyway" just come off as an excuse to me. It
can't satisfy us if it isn't given, but if it were to be there is a chance it might. Even if it didn't, as I mentioned earlier it would give us more to work with when coming up with criticism and suggestions. As such, however trival the information might be, it can only benefit the discussion for them to be transparent.
They may be the ones developing the game, but we are all the ones who end up having to play whatever they make it into. That is why healthy communication between them and us is important, as it helps to ensure that what they are making is actually desirable to the community it's being made for.
I doubt anyone is trying to make the dev team look like villains or anything in this, but speaking for myself the intention is merely to either convince them to implement Super Forms, or failing that at least develop a proper understanding as to why they believe doing so to be a bad idea. So far, neither of these goals have been met, and their official explanations on the matter only ever seem to contain small pieces of the puzzle and on occasion can even seem dismissive, as if to say "We have really great reasons for doing it like this, trust us." when what we really want to hear is "The decision making process that lead to us coming to this conclusion involved this, this, and this." Failure to deliver this information only plants the seeds of doubt that it even exists, making the controversy even worse.