Dark Warrior said:
You shouldn't care JUST about whether or not he can make a wad. Making a wad for the sake of making a wad is stupid. A recolor is often defined as a cheap way of setting yourself up as a person who can "wad". Which is annoying, because it shows no originality/enthusiasm/etc. So, yes, you SHOULD be critical of a recolor.
I'm just going to say right now that when (not if, but when) I do make my recolor, I am NOT going to claim myself as a wad maker. I don't want a title. I simply want to use the wad in online games, because of FUN, which is a concept that you simply cannot grasp if you have to be critical of someone just because they want to have fun.