Cue
ALAM STOP BREAKING THE S
Super mystic sonic said:I'm not sure if this would work out well if fans of a certain wad could bring wads back from death that landed in the banana/newbie/whatever area, considering n00b wads are also praised by n00bs, and could be brought back by those guys.
Resulting in a reason to ban them, thus lowering the total 'n00b' count.
Super mystic sonic said:I'm both for and against this idea. The good point is that you can seperate good from bad, and it could force people to realise that their work sucks. But people could also just judge from the screens and move a decent wad, or just automaticly trow a wad away judging by the previous version of that wad.
This is why the critics would be chosen very carefully, to make sure that they were firm but fair with their actions.
Super mystic sonic said:Being friends with the mod critics could save your wad too. And then there's the problem with taste, and a mod critic constantly moving his/her own crappy wads back to where it doesn't belong.
Same as above, if they were responsible critics they would not treat people differently because of who they are.
Also, a mod critic would not make 'crappy' wads and think they were awesome, they would be chosen because they know what a bad wad is like, so they would know if theirs was terrible.
Oh, and they would probably only have moderator rights in the editing and releases forum, not the banana basket.