Sorry, but it really seems like you didn't read my wall of text that I posted a few pages ago. I made it clear that valid criticism only is what can be explained and justified. I can't imagine such thing as a "happy perfect medium", because it makes no sense. You did not explain why it should be a medium, you did not explain why Chuckles itself isn't a good replacement, you just said you would prefer an in-between of 2.0 Knuckles and Chuckles. I would understand if it was just an opinion, but the thing is that you keep bringing it up everytime Knuckles is mentioned on this thread. It's pretentious.
To make it clear, the Chuckles version was solely based on multiple official Knuckles references, and through out the whole process of it, I have taken as much feedback, criticism, and notes as possible to keep it at it's finest. It was made to LOOK LIKE Knuckles as much as possible, due to the previous SRB2 design looking different and younger, due to looking rather small and shorter than Sonic, which is wrong since Knuckles has always been taller. That all being said, I'm sorry, but I can't see why you keep bringing it up that Chuckles isn't a good replacement and that a medium should be made, and I don't get how it's a happy medium either. We got something that actually resembles Knuckles now, so can you explain why do you find a happy medium so important to the point of keep bringing it up? It has honestly been annoying me to just say that with no explanations.
For those who are wondering, yes, Chuckles is the new 2.1 Knuckles.