Callum: I'm pretty darn certain that's his votes, not his interpretation of the results.
darkbob1713: I remember FF mentioning something about a lot of e-mails he received for this contest having no attachments. If you know you sent an e-mail to him, that's probably the reason.
Anyways, I'm in a crazy rush here, so I'll keep things brief.
Match _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Boringe by SonicMaster _ 5/10
I dislike point-giving gimmicks like that, sorry. The level design is semi-good, but did you need to place every single bomb ring in a complete dead-end?
Toxic Plant Zone by HyperKnux _ 6/10
You might creep out claustrophobics here, ya know. ;P
Yeah, it's ... tiny. Works somewhat well for a small netgame, but I can see how this would be hell for a larger game.
Rook's Valley Zone by Drake Spyker _ 7/10
First thing I said in the netgame I was in: "Auto-Rail. I can hear Glaber complaining already."
Despite that (I don't personally mind Auto-Rail), it works pretty well. A few design choices here and there that I don't like, and the design seems a bit cramped (not as much as the last map, but still) but aside from that... yeah.
Destiny Islands by Darkness Claw _ 0/10
Er, NO. Completely, utterly unplayable due to the insane lag. Seriously, detail is good, but this is OVERKILL.
Castle de Space by Space K. Green _ 6/10
Confusing, at first, and huge, no doubt. Probably works well for 10+ player netgames, but those are rarely seen anymore.
CTF _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Holding out on voting on these because a three-player netgame doesn't really give me a good idea of how these maps really play. Unfortunately.
Circuit _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Heavenly Fountain Zone by SonicMaster _ 5/10
Me, Kitsune, and Chaos_Knux had an lol of a time trying to play this without the asset pack, that's for sure! ;P
But, yeah, you went a bit too far with balancing things and made it quite difficult for Sonic to get far ahead of Tails.
The waterfall ending was a bit interesting, though.
Aqueduct Circuit Zone by Ezer.Arch _ 7/10
Heh, this seems pretty nice. It's a semi-thokfest, but there are some nice obstacles to throw off people just blindly rushing through.